Minutes of the University Senate Meeting
December 7, 2006
1.
The December meeting
of the University Senate was held at 4:05 p.m. on Thursday, December 7, 2006 in
Room 7, Gamble Hall. Douglas Munski presided.
2.
The following
members of the Senate were present:
Anderson, Cindy
Anderson, Suzanne
Baker, Mary
Behrmann, William
Berne, Jane
Boyd, Robert
Buhr, Jordan
Campbell, Katherine
Covington, Chandice
Cripe, Haylee
Dewar, Graeme
Drewes, Mary
Elbert, Dennis
Elsinga, Lillian
Erickson, Daniel
Ferraro, Richard
Fisher, Jay
Folkestad, Sara
Haskins, James
Heitkamp, Thomasine
Hilliard, Nathaniel
Hume, Wendelin
Iiams, Michele
Iverson, Joneen
Jackson, Jon
Jackson, Margaret
Jacobson, Rachelle
Jeno, Sue
Kitzes, Adam
Koeser, Brandon
Kupchella, Charles
Lane, Jason
LaVenture, Andrew
Lawrence, David
LeBel, Paul
Light, Steven
Lothspeich, Jason
Mahar, Patricia
Marasinghe, Kanishka
Martindale, Nathan
Mayzer, Roni
Moen, Jan
Munski, Douglas
Myers, Bradley
Olsen, Glenn
Owens, Sarah
Perkins, Dexter
Perry, David
Petros, Thomas
Picklo, Matthew
Poochigian, Donald
Potvin, Martha
Rakow, Lana
Rex, Janet
Rice, Daniel
Rieke, Judy
Robertson, Charles
Rosenberger, Thad
Seddoh, Samuel
Smart, Kathy
Smith, Bruce
Stofferahn, Curtis
Stolt, Wilbur
Streibel, Kent
Weisenstein, Greg
Williams, Jim
Wittgraf, Michael
3.
The following
members of the Senate were absent:
Alfonso, Peter
Bass, Gail
Benoit, Joseph
Bradley, April
Faruque, Saleh
Flom-Meland, Cynthia
Gallager, Robert
Gosnold, Will
Jerath, Sukhvarsh
Johnson, Stefan
Kelsch, Steven
Little, Michael
Mamaghani, Iraj
Murphy, Eric
Nowacki, Michael
Rendahl, Stephen
Schnellert, Gary
Venhuizen, Brett
Watson, John
Wilson, H. David
Yurkovich, Eleanor
4.
The following announcements
were made:
5.
The Chair asked for
corrections or additions to the November 2, 2006 minutes. Hearing none, the
minutes were approved as distributed.
6.
The question period
was opened at 4:12 p.m.
Mr. Picklo thanked President Kupchella
for the seed money funding and asked about the status of indirect cost returns.
The President indicated that he approved the draft of a letter on December 7th
to address the matter.
The question period
closed at 4:14 p.m.
7.
Mr. Robertson moved to
accept the annual report of the Senate Library Committee. The motion was seconded and passed
unanimously.
8.
Ms. Moen provided some background information on the issue of
the diversity and pluralism statement being revised and re-inserted in the 2007-2009 UND Academic Catalog. The statement first
was discussed by the Senate in Spring, 2006. At that
time, it was tabled and sent back to the Diversity committee. It is now back at
Senate after work by the Committee and review by the President. Ms. Moen moved and
Mr. Petros seconded to approve the statement.
A question was asked by Mr. Rice regarding the statement on
American Indians. Ms. Moen explained that the statement should be included due
to the UND mission. Mr. Rice expressed concern that the statement should be
strengthened and broadened indicating that the current statement does not
reflect the breadth of our commitment to educate American Indian students. Ms. Jeno indicated that there had been a sentence in that
regard, but it was separated and located later in the statement. That decision
was made to be more inclusive in support of all students. Mr. Petros indicated that the Committee tried to accommodate
all students but still mention the mission to American Indians. Mr. Rice made a
friendly amendment to re-word the fifth sentence to read, “Of special and
particular importance is the University’s longstanding commitment to the
education of American Indian students and to the culture and traditions of the
American Indian people.” The friendly amendment was accepted and the motion was
approved with a vote of 60 for, 1 against and 2 abstentions. (Please see
attachment #1.)
9.
Ms. Anderson moved approval of the candidates for degrees in
December. The motion was seconded and approved with a vote of 62 for and 1
abstention.
10.
Mr. Robertson moved
to accept the Curriculum Committee report. The motion was seconded by Mr.
Martindale and approved unanimously.
11.
President Kupchella presented on the
move to a smoke-free campus environment.
He explained that UND
is establishing itself as a leader in wellness, and the policy would be a move
to begin to fund a more comprehensive worksite wellness program and, ultimately,
to make the campus tobacco-free.
President Kupchella set the context and presented background on the
policy. Currently, we have a no-smoking policy in our buildings; consequently,
the question now is the outdoor environment. Enforcement would not be punitive.
He stated that it is enough to declare a tobacco-free environment and to
support smoking cessation in a variety of approaches. The plan might be phased
in with a target implementation date. He opened the floor for questions.
Mr. Poochigan asked about smokeless tobacco and the President
said yes it would be included in the ban. Mr. Erickson asked if, as a
complement to tobacco free, there might be a policy of alcohol free. President Kupchella said it will be considered. There was a comment regarding the possible
loss of students, visitors, and dignitary visits. Another observation was that
it could impact a number of students that want to live on campus. Mr. Perkins
indicated he was pleased to have the campus pursuing this policy and applauds
the measure and hopes we do more. There was a comment regarding the campus
becoming intrusive in lives and expanding that intrusiveness to the point where
the campus might become hostile. The
President indicated that there will be sensitivity to that and the approach
will be positive. Another comment was that UND has problems enforcing the smoking
policy now. There was a suggestion that there be an identification of problem
areas and they could be addressed by deans or other such approaches.
Mr. Jackson moved
that the Senate Executive Committee draw up a resolution of support for a smoke-free
environment and present it at the January Senate meeting. The motion was
seconded by Mr. Perkins. There was a request by Mr. Haskins to include the suggestion
of a phase-in implementation. Mr. Petros indicated
that would be done. The motion was approved with a vote of 55 for, 1 against
and 4 abstentions.
12.
Ms. Covington presented information on the work of the Maternity
Task Force, which is working on a proposed maternity policy update or
“biological leave.” She explained that the genesis of the Task Force was from a
Council of Deans discussion and the Provost’s decision to establish the Task Force.
Mr. Erickson asked about medical leave for other serious illness and Ms.
Covington explained that that was not included in the charge of the group but
may be a natural progression of a family-friendly leave policy. There was a
question of how work will be covered during the leave with extensive discussion
of resource impact and impact on other faculty when there are resources
lacking. Ms. Potvin shared solutions currently being
used in the College of Arts & Sciences. Ms. Burns indicated that there can
be planning with early knowledge of a pregnancy. Further comment was that
support is needed for those picking up work of those on leave. There was a
question as to whether post-doctoral research fellows have been addressed. Ms.
Covington indicated that not a lot of discussion had occurred regarding post-
docs, residents, and graduate teaching assistants; however, that is planned for
future discussion as are other issue. Ms. Campbell commented about the six-week
leave and suggested there may be various approaches and flexibility to define that
time frame depending on the situation and the area. Ms. Covington indicated
that flexibility already exists and Ms. Potvin agreed
that flexibility is not prohibited by the policy. Ms. Heitkamp
applauded the effort of the Task Force and Ms. Covington indicated that they will
continue their work.
13.
The meeting
adjourned at 5:25 p.m.
Suzanne Anderson
Secretary to the
Senate